secunet cloud vs Hikube — Direktvergleich

Interaktive Fassung: https://comparison.cloud/vergleich/syseleven-vs-hikube

Vendor-neutraler Direktvergleich von secunet cloud und Hikube: Services, Rechenzentren, Kosten und Souveränität — datenbasiert auf comparison.cloud.

Management Summary (Stand 2026-10)

secunet cloud und Hikube positionieren sich als europäische Cloud-Anbieter mit Fokus auf Souveränität, unterscheiden sich jedoch in ihrer operativen Ausrichtung und Portfolio-Tiefe. secunet cloud setzt auf maximale operative Souveränität (10/10) und eine breite Compliance-Basis mit BSI C5, während Hikube durch ein architektonisch integriertes 3-AZ-Design über drei Schweizer Standorte eine hohe Hochverfügbarkeit (10/10) bietet. Beide Anbieter punkten mit technologischer Souveränität (je 9/10) und offenen Standards, was Lock-in-Effekte minimiert. secunet cloud eignet sich besser für regulierte Umgebungen in Deutschland mit hohem Datenschutzbedarf, während Hikube für Schweizer Organisationen mit Fokus auf Resilienz und GPU-Workloads attraktiv ist. Die Preisgestaltung ist bei beiden Anbietern im IaaS-Bereich vergleichbar, wobei Hikube bei GPU-Instanzen und secunet cloud bei Block Storage und Egress Vorteile bietet.

secunet cloud: Stärken

secunet cloud: Zu bedenken

Hikube: Stärken

Hikube: Zu bedenken

secunet cloud wählen, wenn:

Hikube wählen, wenn:

Häufige Fragen: secunet cloud vs Hikube

Was ist der Unterschied zwischen secunet cloud und Hikube?

secunet cloud ist ein deutscher Anbieter mit Fokus auf maximale operative Souveränität (10/10) und breite Compliance (BSI C5), während Hikube ein Schweizer Anbieter mit Fokus auf integrierte Hochverfügbarkeit (10/10) durch 3-AZ-Design ist. secunet cloud bietet ein breiteres Compliance-Portfolio, Hikube ein breiteres Datenbank-Portfolio und günstigere GPU-Preise.

Welcher Anbieter ist souveräner?

secunet cloud erreicht einen SEAL-Score von 8,0/10 (80%) und eine operative Souveränität von 10/10. Hikube erreicht einen SEAL-Score von 6,9/10 (69%) und eine operative Souveränität von 8/10. Beide Anbieter weisen eine technologische Souveränität von 9/10 auf.

Welcher Anbieter ist günstiger?

Das Gesamt-Cost-Rating liegt bei secunet cloud bei 5,2/10 und bei Hikube bei 6,4/10. Hikube bietet günstigere GPU-Instanzen (9,7/10), während secunet cloud günstigeren Block Storage (7,9/10) und Egress (6,9/10) bietet. Tatsächliche Kosten sind workload-abhängig.

Welcher Anbieter bietet bessere Hochverfügbarkeit?

Hikube bietet eine Hochverfügbarkeit von 10/10 (Ø: 6,9/10) durch das 3-AZ-Design über Genf, Gland und Luzern. secunet cloud bietet eine Hochverfügbarkeit von 5/10 (Ø: 6,9/10) mit 5 Availability Zones in Deutschland.

Welcher Anbieter ist besser für KI-Workloads geeignet?

Hikube bietet GPU-Instanzen mit einem Cost-Rating von 9,7/10 und ein AI-Score von 4/10. secunet cloud bietet GPU-Instanzen mit einem Cost-Rating von 6,3/10 und ein AI-Score von 1/10. Hikube ist daher für GPU-lastige KI-Workloads preislich und funktional besser geeignet.

Management Summary

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
Count of Services30+20+
Cost Rating5.2/106.4/10
Saving Plan54%–
Datacenter63
Datacenter ModelColocationColocation
Zone SeparationMulti-site onlySeparate buildings
Server ProductionStandard hardware–
Countries1 (Germany)1
SEAL Score8.0/10 (80%)6.9/10 (69%)
USPGerman cloud platform of secunet, developed and operated by its cloud subsidiary SysEleven GmbH (brand secunet cloud), built for tailored operations, not standardized infrastructure.3 AZ by design: every workload runs active-active across three Swiss datacenters. VM volumes and Kubernetes are replicated by the platform.
RecommendationCustom-operated workloads with strong support requirements in a German cloud environmentRecommended for Swiss organisations and regulated mid-sized companies that want built-in HA resilience without designing it themselves.

Sovereign Cloud

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
InterpretationEU-based sovereign cloud with full GDPR, BSI C5 and KRITIS complianceSwiss operator (ownership chain not publicly evidenced); compute and storage run in three Swiss datacenters, transfers abroad only with consent except in security emergencies or legal obligations. The buildings are colocation sites run by third parties, sub-processor locations are not published, and the platform only opened in 2025
SEALSEAL 3SEAL 3
ResidencyGermanySwitzerland
Shared ResourcesOpenstack CloudCloud Instances
Dedicated ResourcesPrivate Cloud dedicated OpenStack environment in German datacenters–
Dedicated CloudSINA Cloud on-premises OpenStack IaaS for classified data up to GEHEIMHikube (on Prem) on Request
EncryptionSecrets (Barbican)Vault as a Service (secrets management in the Swiss tenant)
Ownership & controlSubsidiary of secunet Security Networks AG (Prime Standard)Hidora SA, Petit-Lancy, Switzerland (not EU), CHE-286.910.173 (commercial register GE/Zefix; AG since 2016, capital CHF 144,750 in restricted registered shares)
EU governance & oversightOnly the statutory supervisory board of secunet AG (six members: four shareholder, two employee representatives; incl. Wintergerst (CEO G+D), Thyen (CFO G+D))No independent board or advisory body with veto/oversight rights (checked: about, imprint, security & compliance, GTC)
Third-country access riskControlling ownership chain German, no US parent (G+D GmbH (majority shareholder) → listed secunet AG → SysEleven GmbH)Hidora SA, Switzerland (not EU) (ownership chain not publicly evidenced)
Contracting entity & jurisdictionContract solely with the relevant secunet company (Cloud T&Cs § 1, incl. SysEleven GmbH; § 27 German law, German courts)Contracting party HIDORA SA, Petit-Lancy; Swiss law, Geneva courts (GTC October 2026 clause 21; CHE-286.910.173; Switzerland (not EU))
Transparency on authority requestsNo transparency report on government requests (checked: data sovereignty page, T&Cs/SLA, privacy policy, press news, documentation)No transparency report on government requests (checked: security & compliance, CLOUD Act guide (2026-06-10, upd. 2026-08-21), resources, blog)
Data residency incl. backups/DRData not forwarded to other regions or countries (service description 17 Nov 2025; regions HAM1/DUS2, object storage replicated DUS2→HAM1)Operated from Swiss DCs: Geneva (Plan-les-Ouates), Gland, Lucerne (Hikube service agreement October 2026, clause 3 and Annex A; Switzerland (EU adequacy decision))
Metadata & support data residencyNo commitment on residency of telemetry, log, billing or support dataAncillary processing 'may involve subcontractors' (service agreement October 2026 clause 3: anti-DDoS, monitoring, support)
AI services: processing & training'Managed LLM' is a marketing statement only (no model list, no processing location, no no-training commitment)Not applicable: no managed AI service (GPU as a Service only, 6 NVIDIA cards L4–H200 on VMs/node groups; 'no opaque ML PaaS')
Dedicated / segregated environmentSINA Cloud onPrem: dedicated, in the customer data centre (no connection to external cloud services, self-operated, up to GEHEIM)Managed Kubernetes control plane dedicated to your cluster (own API server, own etcd, 'shared with nobody'; workers in own tenant)
EU operations & supportService hours exclude Berlin public holidays; 24/7 emergency hotline (+49 30 609 89 22 11)Support by Hidora SA engineers in Geneva (support page 2026-08-23; business days 08:00–18:00 CET, 24×7 infrastructure on-call)
Technical operator lock-outOnly object storage SSE-C with customer-supplied key (256-bit key per request, 'the server never stores your keys')No confidential computing, no attestation, no HYOK
Disconnected / autonomous operationSINA Cloud: on-prem OpenStack/Kubernetes, up to GEHEIM per vendor (secunet product)Control plane operated exclusively in Switzerland (guide 2026-07-15, upd. 2026-09-07: Geneva, Gland and Lucerne; Switzerland (not EU))
Hardware origin & manufacturingSINA Cloud 'runs on any common hardware' per vendor (commodity server hardware without vendor lock-in, independent procurement)Only the GPU vendor disclosed: NVIDIA (six cards L4 24G, L40S 48G, A100 80G, RTX 6000 Pro 96G, H100 80G, H200 141G)
Critical software dependenciesBased on OpenStack, 'open source under Apache licence' (vendor-independent; MetaKube (Kubernetes) and Red Hat OpenShift also in the portfolio)Partially disclosed: Talos Linux, Cilium, Grafana, VictoriaMetrics (Managed Kubernetes page; VictoriaLogs, cert-manager)
Open-source share & patch authorityCore: OpenStack on own base, CNCF-certified Kubernetes (MetaKube) (Terraform examples MIT)Managed OSS services: OpenBAO, Harbor/Trivy, Grafana, MariaDB (release notes Hikube v1.1.2 (19 Mar 2026); OpenBAO = open-source fork of HashiCorp Vault; RabbitMQ)
Portability & exitSwitch any time, transition period at most two months (cloud switching terms (EU Data Act, as of 14 Nov 2025))Reversibility: return 'in a reasonable standard format' (GTC Oct 2026 cl. 9.2; content kept thirty (30) days after termination, then deletion (Annex D cl. 11))
IaC & automationMetaKube via HTTP JSON API or Terraform provider (public MetaKube OpenAPI spec; service account as bearer token, Terraform example)Public REST/JSON API with OpenAPI 2.0 specification (api.hikube.cloud: VMs, disks, S3 buckets, Kubernetes, VPC, databases, backups, GPU, pricing)
Key sovereignty (BYOK/HYOK, EU HSM)gp1e volumes: own 256-bit AES-XTS key per volume (downloadable from the project key store; object storage SSE-C with customer key)Vault as a Service in your Swiss tenant, operated by Hidora ('without US KMS or US Vault'; 'no self-operated HSM')
Certifications & scopeBSI C5 Type 2; ISO 27001:2022 native and on IT-Grundschutz basis (certificate ID 27001-27600152; also ISO 27017/27018)ISO 27001 'certified by SQS' per the provider ('the PDF is not online'; attestation, scope annex, validity date on request only)
Public audit evidencePublic: Cloud T&Cs, switching terms, service descriptions with SLA (public cloud SLA 99.9 % per calendar month)Public only: GTC, Hikube contract, privacy notice, status page
EU labels & schemesSCS monitor lists SysEleven only under 'Non-certified environments' (SysEleven GmbH, Public OpenStack Cloud, 2 SCS regions; SCS certification not confirmed)No EUCS, Gaia-X, EU Cloud CoC, CISPE, SecNumCloud or Cloud III SEAL (no BSI C3A; Swiss provider (not EU))
Energy & CO₂ transparencyDüsseldorf/Hamburg: '100 % green power', 'PUE below 1.3' (vendor figures; free-air cooling, EN 50600 Level 3)'No PUE published'; 100% renewable power at three sites (infrastructure page; Gland approx. 6.9 g CO₂-eq/kWh, Geneva waste heat up to 4.4 MW (CAD-ZIPLO))
Climate commitmentsISO 14001 'since 2024', electricity 100 % renewable 'since 2026' (secunet group page; ISO 14001 scope open)No own climate targets (Hidora/Hikube not in the Climate Neutral Data Centre Pact public register)

SEAL Framework

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
Sovereignty Score8.0/10 (80%) secunet-owned German cloud on open-source stack6.9/10 (69%) Swiss operator (ownership chain not publicly evidenced) on an open-source stack in colocation sites; own compliance certification ISO 27001
SOV-1 Strategic (15 %)Owned by secunet, German listed security companyFounder-led Swiss company Hidora SA; ownership chain not publicly evidenced; small provider, platform launched in 2025
SOV-2 Legal & Jurisdictional (10 %)German jurisdiction onlySwiss jurisdiction (nFADP), no US parent; EU adequacy decision for Switzerland covers transfers from the EU
SOV-3 Data & AI (10 %)Data in German datacentersData in three Swiss datacenters; transfers abroad only with consent, except in security emergencies or legal obligations; dedicated GPUs, but no managed AI services
SOV-4 Operational (15 %)German staff and datacentersOperated and supported by Swiss-based engineers; buildings (power, cooling, physical access) are run by third-party site operators
SOV-5 Supply Chain (20 %)EU datacenters; standard hardware sourcingColocation in three third-party buildings (Stack Infrastructure, backed by US investor IPI Partners, in Geneva and Gland; EWL in Lucerne); hardware sourced on the global market
SOV-6 Technology (15 %)OpenStack & Kubernetes, no proprietary lock-inOpen-source, Kubernetes-native stack (Talos Linux, Cilium, OpenBAO, upstream PostgreSQL/MariaDB/Redis/Kafka), S3 API, kubectl/Helm/GitOps, VMDK/QCOW2/ISO import; hypervisor and storage layer not disclosed
SOV-7 Security & Compliance (10 %)ISO 27001; secunet security lineageISO 27001 (operator ISMS, certified by SQS; certificate not published online); no C5, SOC 2, ISO 27017/27018; SLA 99.99% per service published (GPU passthrough and preview services excluded); RPO/RTO not published (Hidora states < 5 min, publication announced)
SOV-8 Environmental (5 %)Limited public sustainability commitments100% renewable power at all three sites, heat reuse in Geneva and Lucerne; no PUE published, ISO 14001/50001 are building certificates

Availability & Locations

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
Presence DACHGermanySwitzerland
Presence EuropeGermany Berlin, FrankfurtSwitzerland Geneva (Plan-les-Ouates), Gland, Lucerne
Availability Zones53
Multi-AZ (angekündigt)✓ verfügbar
Regions51
Countries11
Continents11
Point of Presence50+–
Dedicated Backbone✓ verfügbar–
DDoS✓ verfügbar–

Compute

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
Shared InstanceServers 1vCPU-32vCPUCloud Instances s1 / u1 / m1, 1vCPU-64vCPU
GPU InstanceServers - GPU optimized NVIDIA A30, L40S, H100 NVL, H200 NVLGPU Cloud NVIDIA L4, L40S, A100, RTX 6000 Pro, H100, H200
Windows ServerSelf-Service Custom ImagesWindows Server licence (incl. 2025, per vCPU)

Hot Storage

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
Block StorageVolumesBlock Storage 3x Replicated NVMe, sync or async across 3 datacenters
AssetsObject Storage S3 API only (no bucket UI), geo-replicated DUS2/HAM1Swiss S3 Object Storage (S3 API, WORM)
FileNFS Shares (Manila) NFSv4, available on request–

Cold Storage

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
VM BackupManaged VM optional backup integrationBackup as a Service
Volume BackupVolume SnapshotVelero (Kubernetes add-on)
Disaster Recovery–3-datacenter replication by design (restart on the remaining sites)

Managed Databases

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
MySQLManaged VM MariaDBManaged MariaDB
PostGreDBaaS PostgreSQL, HA cluster, point-in-time recoveryManaged PostgreSQL (CloudNativePG)
Document-OrientedNoSQL (angekündigt)Managed MongoDB
CacheManaged VM redisManaged Redis (Sentinel)
Search EngineManaged VM opensearch–
Distributed Wide-Column–Managed ClickHouse
Vector–Managed Qdrant

Network & Security

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
NetworkNetworksVPC & Subnets
Public IPFloating IPsPublic IPv4
GatewayRouters–
Load BalancerLoad Balancer Octavia Amphora (L4/L7), OVN (Early Access)Managed Ingress (ingress-nginx, Gateway API)
Public DNSDNS–
FirewallFWaaSPer-VM firewall (allowed inbound ports on the public IP; SSH 22 default, HTTP/HTTPS optional)
Private ConnectivityVPNaaSSite-to-site VPN (on request)
Dedicated ConnectivityDirect Connect 100 Mbit/s, 1G, 10G–
DDoS ProtectionDDoS Guard Free/Plus/Premium/Enterprise, Layer 3-7–

Orchestration

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
OrchestrationMetaKube CoreManaged Kubernetes
Container Registry–Registry as a Service

Virtualization

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
HypervisorKVM (OpenStack-based)Not disclosed (VM layer operated by Hikube; VMDK / QCOW2 / ISO import)
Instance as a ServiceManaged VMCloud Instances
Edge VirtualizationSINA Cloud on-premises turnkey platform (hardware, software, services)–

Management

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
Identity ManagementIAMOrganizations & Projects (isolated projects with quotas, members and roles; API keys per project)
IaCTerraform Provider sys11iam (Beta)Hikube public API (REST/JSON, OpenAPI 2.0 spec)
Audit TrailAudit Logging (angekündigt)–
Command LineOpenStack CLIkubectl / Helm
CollaborationGitLab aaS single instance or HA setup–

Big Data

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
Dashboardssecunet cloud Observability (Early Access) Grafana Mimir metrics, Loki logsGrafana (Monitoring Agents add-on, per cluster)
MessagingManaged VM rabbitmqManaged RabbitMQ
Log Monitoringsecunet cloud Observability (Early Access) Loki logs, 1 month default retentionMonitoring Agents add-on
Data Streaming–Managed Kafka
Big Data Plattform–Managed ClickHouse (OLAP)

AI & Machine Learning

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
AssistantClassified AI (Private Cloud AI) on-prem, air-gapped chatbots & copilots for internal knowledge (classified data)–
Dedicated InferenceManaged LLMs (on request) on secunet cloud GPU infrastructure; no public model list or pricing–
AI AgentsAI Runtime aaS for classified data Haystack (deepset) agent orchestration; with Red Hat AI Factory and NVIDIA (angekündigt)–
RAG & GroundingClassified AI (Private Cloud AI) on-prem, air-gapped RAG for chatbots, intelligent search, knowledge management–
Sovereign / On-Prem AIClassified AI (Private Cloud AI) HPE + NVIDIA on SINA Cloud; on-prem, air-gapped; classified data up to SECRET (per secunet)–
Machine Learning–GPU as a Service (dedicated NVIDIA GPUs on VMs or Kubernetes node groups)

Compliance & Certificates

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
C5\nGerman cloud security catalogue✓ verfügbar–
ISO 27001\nInformation security management system✓ verfügbar✓ verfügbar
ISO 27017\nCloud security controls for providers✓ verfügbar–
ISO 27018\nPersonal data protection for cloud✓ verfügbar–
VS-NfD\nGerman classified-information handlingSINA Cloud aaS Individual BSI use permits (S3 Proxy, Security Layer) up to VS-NfD, limited to 2027–

Cost Indication

Servicesecunet cloudHikube
Rating5.2/106.4/10
CPU vCPU/h3.6/10 0,0398873 €6.2/10 0,0119212 €
GPU H100/h6.3/10 5,6584000 €9.7/10 2,9785142 €
RAM GB/h7.0/10 0,0023859 €3.0/10 0,0119212 €
Managed MySQL Ratio1/44.2/10 0,0748000 €4.2/10 0,0744966 €
Block Storage GB/h | 3000 IOPS7.9/10 0,0000890 €5.7/10 0,0002719 €
S3 Storage GB/h3.3/10 0,0000340 €4.0/10 0,0000298 €
Archive Storage GB/h3.0/10 0,0000274 €–
Kubernetes-Service-Premium Cluster/h4.5/10 0,1000000 €8.5/10 0,0476848 €
Egress per GB6.9/10 0,0076228 €10.0/10 0,0000000 €

Einzelprofile