Vendor-neutraler Direktvergleich von Scaleway und Hikube: Services, Rechenzentren, Kosten und Souveränität — datenbasiert auf comparison.cloud.
Scaleway positioniert sich als kosteneffiziente, souveräne EU-Cloud mit einem breiten Portfolio aus 80+ Services, das stark auf Bare Metal, Cloud-Native-Entwicklung und KI-Infrastruktur ausgerichtet ist. Im Gegensatz dazu fokussiert sich Hikube als Schweizer Anbieter auf eine architektonisch integrierte Hochverfügbarkeit, bei der jede Workload standardmäßig aktiv-aktiv über drei Rechenzentren in Genf, Gland und Luzern läuft. Während Scaleway mit einem SEAL Score von 7,9/10 und einer hohen operativen Souveränität (9/10) punktet, bietet Hikube mit einem SEAL Score von 6,9/10 eine spezifische Resilienz-Lösung für den Schweizer Markt. Für Unternehmen, die ein breites Spektrum an Infrastruktur- und KI-Diensten zu wettbewerbsfähigen Preisen suchen, ist Scaleway die passende Wahl. Hikube eignet sich hingegen besonders für Organisationen, die eine eingebaute Multi-Site-Resilienz ohne eigene Design-Aufwände bevorzugen und primär in der Schweiz operieren.
Scaleway ist ein französischer Anbieter mit einem breiten Portfolio von über 80 Services, der sich auf Bare Metal, Cloud-Native-Entwicklung und KI spezialisiert hat und in vier europäischen Ländern präsent ist. Hikube ist ein Schweizer Anbieter mit einem kleineren Portfolio von über 20 Services, der sich auf eine architektonisch integrierte 3-AZ-Hochverfügbarkeit innerhalb der Schweiz konzentriert. Während Scaleway auf Breite und Preiswettbewerbsfähigkeit setzt, bietet Hikube spezifische Resilienz für den Schweizer Markt.
Scaleway erzielt einen höheren SEAL Score von 7,9/10 (79 %) im Vergleich zu 6,9/10 (69 %) bei Hikube. Beide Anbieter weisen eine hohe technologische Souveränität von 9/10 auf. Scaleway punktet mit einer höheren operativen Souveränität (9/10) gegenüber Hikube (8/10), was auf eine stärkere Unabhängigkeit von nicht-europäischen Interventionen hindeutet.
Scaleway hat einen Preis-Score von 9/10 (Ø: 6,4/10) und ein Cost Rating von 6,2/10, während Hikube einen Preis-Score von 6/10 und ein Cost Rating von 6,4/10 aufweist. Scaleway bietet zudem bis zu 25 % Rabatt über Saving Plans. Die tatsächlichen Kosten sind jedoch stark von der spezifischen Workload und den genutzten Services abhängig.
Hikube bietet mit einem Score von 10/10 (Ø: 6,9/10) die höchste Resilienz im Vergleichsfeld, da jede Workload standardmäßig aktiv-aktiv über drei Schweizer Rechenzentren läuft. Scaleway bietet Multi-AZ-Fähigkeiten in vier Regionen, erzielt aber einen Score von 6/10 (Ø: 6,9/10) für Hochverfügbarkeit.
Scaleway bietet ein umfassenderes KI-Portfolio mit einem Score von 6/10 (Ø: 4,8/10), einschließlich Generative APIs, Serverless Inference und Managed Inference. Hikube bietet GPU as a Service mit einem Score von 4/10 (Ø: 4,8/10) und sehr günstigen GPU-Preisen (9,7/10), hat aber ein kleineres Portfolio an KI-Diensten.
| Service | Scaleway | Hikube |
| Interpretation | With headquarters in the EU, data is inherently sovereign. No extra European tech dependency (everything is home built, open source or with EU Partners) | Swiss operator (ownership chain not publicly evidenced); compute and storage run in three Swiss datacenters, transfers abroad only with consent except in security emergencies or legal obligations. The buildings are colocation sites run by third parties, sub-processor locations are not published, and the platform only opened in 2025 |
| SEAL | SEAL 3 | SEAL 3 |
| Residency | France | Switzerland |
| Shared Resources | Scaleway | Cloud Instances |
| Dedicated Resources | Dedibox | – |
| Dedicated Cloud | Private Regions (angekündigt) | Hikube (on Prem) on Request |
| Encryption | Key Manager | Vault as a Service (secrets management in the Swiss tenant) |
| Ownership & control | Scaleway SAS, Paris, an iliad subsidiary (per about page; iliad→Scaleway stake not disclosed) | Hidora SA, Petit-Lancy, Switzerland (not EU), CHE-286.910.173 (commercial register GE/Zefix; AG since 2016, capital CHF 144,750 in restricted registered shares) |
| EU governance & oversight | No independent EU oversight body with veto rights (about page, legal notice, SecNumCloud page, Trust Center checked) | No independent board or advisory body with veto/oversight rights (checked: about, imprint, security & compliance, GTC) |
| Third-country access risk | DPA bars disclosure to third-country authorities, with exceptions (DPA 1 Jun 2024 art. 3.1.7: unless data outside the EU, international agreement or GDPR art. 49) | Hidora SA, Switzerland (not EU) (ownership chain not publicly evidenced) |
| Contracting entity & jurisdiction | Contracting entity Scaleway SAS, Paris, French law (GTS 7 Apr 2026 art. 22/23; RCS 433 115 904; Paris commercial court) | Contracting party HIDORA SA, Petit-Lancy; Swiss law, Geneva courts (GTC October 2026 clause 21; CHE-286.910.173; Switzerland (not EU)) |
| Transparency on authority requests | No report on authority requests for customer data | No transparency report on government requests (checked: security & compliance, CLOUD Act guide (2026-06-10, upd. 2026-08-21), resources, blog) |
| Data residency incl. backups/DR | Services within the EU by default, region chosen at order (DPA art. 11.1; customer selects region/AZ) | Operated from Swiss DCs: Geneva (Plan-les-Ouates), Gland, Lucerne (Hikube service agreement October 2026, clause 3 and Annex A; Switzerland (EU adequacy decision)) |
| Metadata & support data residency | Scaleway 'strives' to minimise transfers outside the EU (privacy policy; support, payment, marketing partners under SCCs possible, locations not named) | Ancillary processing 'may involve subcontractors' (service agreement October 2026 clause 3: anti-DDoS, monitoring, support) |
| AI services: processing & training | Generative APIs: storage region Paris, Zero Data Retention (privacy policy reviewed October 2025) | Not applicable: no managed AI service (GPU as a Service only, 6 NVIDIA cards L4–H200 on VMs/node groups; 'no opaque ML PaaS') |
| Dedicated / segregated environment | Elastic Metal: 100 % dedicated machine without hypervisor (zones PAR1/2, AMS1/2, WAW2/3, not Milan) | Managed Kubernetes control plane dedicated to your cluster (own API server, own etcd, 'shared with nobody'; workers in own tenant) |
| EU operations & support | Customer Care at the Paris 8 main office, 24/7 tickets (support page, website statement; French/English) | Support by Hidora SA engineers in Geneva (support page 2026-08-23; business days 08:00–18:00 CET, 24×7 infrastructure on-call) |
| Technical operator lock-out | No confidential computing, attestation or HYOK found (Instances, Elastic Metal, Key Manager docs checked) | No confidential computing, no attestation, no HYOK |
| Disconnected / autonomous operation | No on-premises, air-gapped or local control-plane offer (products availability, news Apr–Oct 2026, shared-responsibility page checked) | Control plane operated exclusively in Switzerland (guide 2026-07-15, upd. 2026-09-07: Geneva, Gland and Lucerne; Switzerland (not EU)) |
| Hardware origin & manufacturing | RISC-V server EM-RV1 built in-house in Paris (blog: launched 29 Feb 2024, Paris 2; blades/chassis 'every manufacturing step in-house') | Only the GPU vendor disclosed: NVIDIA (six cards L4 24G, L40S 48G, A100 80G, RTX 6000 Pro 96G, H100 80G, H200 141G) |
| Critical software dependencies | Stack 'free from non-European technological dependencies' (SecNumCloud page, provider statement; Object Storage in-house, open source Kubernetes) | Partially disclosed: Talos Linux, Cilium, Grafana, VictoriaMetrics (Managed Kubernetes page; VictoriaLogs, cert-manager) |
| Open-source share & patch authority | Tooling open on GitHub, platform core proprietary (CLI Apache-2.0, Terraform provider, Packer, Ansible, SDKs Go/JS/Python, K8s integrations) | Managed OSS services: OpenBAO, Harbor/Trivy, Grafana, MariaDB (release notes Hikube v1.1.2 (19 Mar 2026); OpenBAO = open-source fork of HashiCorp Vault; RabbitMQ) |
| Portability & exit | Customer-defined reversibility plan, API export tools (GTS version 07/04/2026 art. 13.3; exportable data in machine-readable formats on request) | Reversibility: return 'in a reasonable standard format' (GTC Oct 2026 cl. 9.2; content kept thirty (30) days after termination, then deletion (Annex D cl. 11)) |
| IaC & automation | Versioned API: v1 GA, v1beta1 beta, v1alpha1 alpha (versions in the URI path; old version stays available, users warned before removal) | Public REST/JSON API with OpenAPI 2.0 specification (api.hikube.cloud: VMs, disks, S3 buckets, Kubernetes, VPC, databases, backups, GPU, pricing) |
| Key sovereignty (BYOK/HYOK, EU HSM) | Key Manager in PAR/AMS/WAW/MIL, BYOK import AES only (AES-256-GCM, RSA-OAEP, ECDSA, ML-KEM/ML-DSA; keys non-exportable) | Vault as a Service in your Swiss tenant, operated by Hidora ('without US KMS or US Vault'; 'no self-operated HSM') |
| Certifications & scope | ISO/IEC 27001:2022 IS 787020 (BSI), valid to 5 Dec 2026 (scope: infrastructure platform for Public Cloud products; Paris/Lille, OpCore DC2–5, AMS/WAW) | ISO 27001 'certified by SQS' per the provider ('the PDF is not online'; attestation, scope annex, validity date on request only) |
| Public audit evidence | GTS, DPA, TOMs and intrusion testing agreement public as PDF (contracts page; Shared Responsibility Model linked) | Public only: GTC, Hikube contract, privacy notice, status page |
| EU labels & schemes | SEAL-3 in the EU Cloud III sovereign cloud tender (European Commission, 17 Apr 2026, Cloud Sovereignty Framework; Scaleway (Iliad Group)) | No EUCS, Gaia-X, EU Cloud CoC, CISPE, SecNumCloud or Cloud III SEAL (no BSI C3A; Swiss provider (not EU)) |
| Energy & CO₂ transparency | PUE/WUE published per data center (fr-par-1 1.45, fr-par-2 1.16, nl-ams-3 1.20, pl-waw-1 1.50; docs reviewed June 2025) | 'No PUE published'; 100% renewable power at three sites (infrastructure page; Gland approx. 6.9 g CO₂-eq/kWh, Geneva waste heat up to 4.4 MW (CAD-ZIPLO)) |
| Climate commitments | ISO 50001:2018 held by OPCORE, not Scaleway SAS (BSI register ENMS 609673, valid to 4 Jan 2027; DCs PAR1–PAR5, MARS1, LYO1, not AMS/WAW/MIL) | No own climate targets (Hidora/Hikube not in the Climate Neutral Data Centre Pact public register) |
| Service | Scaleway | Hikube |
| Sovereignty Score | 7.9/10 (79%) EU-owned (iliad); EU sovereign cloud tender awardee 2026 | 6.9/10 (69%) Swiss operator (ownership chain not publicly evidenced) on an open-source stack in colocation sites; own compliance certification ISO 27001 |
| SOV-1
Strategic (15 %) | French iliad Group ownership | Founder-led Swiss company Hidora SA; ownership chain not publicly evidenced; small provider, platform launched in 2025 |
| SOV-2
Legal & Jurisdictional (10 %) | EU (French) jurisdiction only | Swiss jurisdiction (nFADP), no US parent; EU adequacy decision for Switzerland covers transfers from the EU |
| SOV-3
Data & AI (10 %) | EU residency; European AI cloud push | Data in three Swiss datacenters; transfers abroad only with consent, except in security emergencies or legal obligations; dedicated GPUs, but no managed AI services |
| SOV-4
Operational (15 %) | EU staff, group-owned Paris-region datacenters | Operated and supported by Swiss-based engineers; buildings (power, cooling, physical access) are run by third-party site operators |
| SOV-5
Supply Chain (20 %) | Group datacenters (OpCore), hardware reuse program | Colocation in three third-party buildings (Stack Infrastructure, backed by US investor IPI Partners, in Geneva and Gland; EWL in Lucerne); hardware sourced on the global market |
| SOV-6
Technology (15 %) | Open standards, explicit anti lock-in positioning | Open-source, Kubernetes-native stack (Talos Linux, Cilium, OpenBAO, upstream PostgreSQL/MariaDB/Redis/Kafka), S3 API, kubectl/Helm/GitOps, VMDK/QCOW2/ISO import; hypervisor and storage layer not disclosed |
| SOV-7
Security & Compliance (10 %) | ISO 27001, HDS; SecNumCloud not yet qualified | ISO 27001 (operator ISMS, certified by SQS; certificate not published online); no C5, SOC 2, ISO 27017/27018; SLA 99.99% per service published (GPU passthrough and preview services excluded); RPO/RTO not published (Hidora states < 5 min, publication announced) |
| SOV-8
Environmental (5 %) | Adiabatic cooling (DC5), sustainability leadership | 100% renewable power at all three sites, heat reuse in Geneva and Lucerne; no PUE published, ISO 14001/50001 are building certificates |